Across the Shopify stores we've audited, the pattern is consistent: a store can score 95+ on technical readiness and still not be named when someone asks an AI assistant what to buy. The assistants mostly repeat what trusted "best of" roundups say. In home and bedding, eight brands show up for more than half the stores we checked — and they're the brands those roundups cover year after year.
So the useful question is: how does a smaller brand get into the roundups?
Step 1: Find the sources that matter for your questions
Don't start from a generic PR list. Start from the answers.
- Write down the 5–10 questions your customers would ask: "best linen duvet cover", "best towels for a small bathroom", "best organic crib sheets".
- Ask each one in Perplexity, which lists its sources under the answer. In ChatGPT and Gemini, follow up with "what sources did you use?".
- Put every cited page in a spreadsheet: publication, article title, URL, last-updated date, and which brands it names.
After 10 questions you will usually see the same 5–8 articles over and over. Those are your targets. In our bedding audits the recurring publishers were Forbes, HGTV, Good Housekeeping, The New York Times, Yahoo Shopping, Sleep Foundation, NBC News and Reviewed — but your category will have its own list, including niche review sites that a generic PR list would miss.
Step 2: Read how each roundup is made
Open each target article and look for three things, usually near the top or bottom:
- How they test. "We slept on 30 sets of sheets for six weeks" means they need product to test. "Based on customer reviews" means they need reviews somewhere they can see them.
- When it's updated. Most "best of" lists are refreshed once or twice a year. A note like "updated September 2026" tells you when the next refresh is likely.
- Who writes it. There is almost always a named writer or a product-testing editor. That's who you contact — not a general inbox.
Many shopping roundups also earn affiliate commission on the products they link. If every brand on a list links through the same affiliate network, being reachable on that network can matter as much as the pitch. Check whether you're on it.
Step 3: Pitch one thing, to one person, with a sample
Editors get hundreds of pitches. The ones that work are short and specific:
- One product, not your catalog. Pick the product that fits their article: "your best linen sheets list has nothing under $150 — ours are $129, stonewashed European flax."
- A reason it belongs. A gap in the current list (price point, material, size, a use case like hot sleepers) beats "we'd love to be featured".
- An easy yes. Offer to send a sample to their testing address. Don't attach a press kit; link to one page with photos, specs and price.
Then follow up once, around their likely refresh date. Expect a low hit rate — one placement on a list the assistants actually cite is worth more than ten on lists they don't.
Step 4: Build the signals roundups and assistants both read
Writers and AI assistants both look for evidence that real people like a product.
- Reviews in more than one place. Your own site, plus wherever shoppers in your category look — Google, marketplaces you sell on, and community sites. Assistants sometimes cite Reddit and YouTube directly.
- Reviews that machines can read. On your own product pages, make sure star ratings are in the page's structured data, not just drawn by JavaScript. Our ratings guide shows the 10-minute check.
- Consistent facts everywhere. Same product name, price, materials and sizes on your site, in your feed and on retailer pages. An editor fact-checking you — or an assistant summarising you — shouldn't find three different versions.
Step 5: Re-check, don't assume
Placement in a roundup doesn't show up in AI answers the next day. Re-ask your 5–10 questions monthly, note who's named and which sources are cited, and watch for your brand to appear — first in the sources, then in the answers.
Feedlegible's Growth plan re-asks your questions every week, but you can do it by hand with the spreadsheet from Step 1. Either way, measure it: "we got featured" and "the assistants now name us" are different results.
The short version
- The assistants copy a small set of articles. Find yours by asking your customers' questions and listing the sources.
- Read how each article is made, then pitch one product to the named writer, with a reason and a sample.
- Make your reviews and product facts visible and consistent, so both editors and assistants can verify you.
- Re-check monthly.
Not sure where you stand today? The free audit shows the answers for your store's two most likely shopping questions, and who's named instead.